Location: Kelly's Tavern; Newport News
TOPIC: Wizardry in literature. Where's the line?
- Is Harry Potter "good Christian literature" or "straight from hell?"
- What if J.K. Rowling isn't a Christian...or is a lousy Christian? Is that a show stopper for reading her work? (Try looking here)
- Is Gandalf part of the "lavender brigade?" (see Phillips below) How about Aslan?
- Is loving the work of Lewis and/or Tolkein while despising Rowling intellectually honest based upon the reasons we often give? Or, is it a bit of mental gymnastics?
- Does it matter if the setting is fantasy or recognizable as our world? If so, why?
- If I'm pro-HP (and honest) then to what else must I give approval?
- If I'm anti-HP (and honest) then what else must I abhor?
- Given that God is sovereign, is it coincidence that the 7th HP book will be released on 7/07/07 (that's a lot of 7s) when 7 is the "number of spiritual perfection?"
Beware, some of these folks might challenge your thinking...whichever side you're on. This issue may not be as simplistic as you think...or maybe it is...hmmmmm?
- Don't know anything...here's the Wiki article so you can at least get a plot sketch
- Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix [Opens July 11th] (Movie official site)
- JK Rowling Official Site
- Looking for God in Harry Potter (John Granger's book - Amazon){If you're convinced HP is evil then you should read this one}
- John Granger's blog - Hogwarts Professor
- John Granger Interview
- Looking for God in HP (Joost Nixon's SAP review - see #11)
- Harry Potter, Narnia, and The Lord of the Rings: What You Need to Know About Fantasy Books and Movies (Richard Abanes' book - Amazon){If you're convinced HP is good then you should read this one}
- "Defending Harry Potter" (Joel Miller - WND)
- "Harry Potter and the Lavender Brigade (Doug Phillips' blog)
- "Most Real Fantasy" (Douglas Jones - Credenda Agenda)
- "Potter's Magic" (Ben Merkle-Credenda Agenda)
- "More Clay than Potter" (Anne McCain - Charlottesville, VA Director of Children's Education, Trinity PCA)
- "Funamentalism vs. Reformed Theology" (Monergism.com)
- "Harry Potter vs. Gandalf - An in-depth analysis of the literary use of magic in the works of J.K. Rowling, J.R.R. Tolkein, and C.S. Lewis" (Decentfilms.com)
- Roman Catholic Apologist's page with many pro/con/ambiguous links (check about 1/2 way down the page)
- HP leads to rise in Satanism among children debunked (Snopes.com)
No comments:
Post a Comment